AMERICA,
ISRAEL AND THE TALIBAN …
…
are they really so different?
Whenever
we talk about the Taliban in Afghanistan, we rightfully focus on what they ban.
Women
cannot attend universities. Girls are shut out of secondary schools. Women face
harsh restrictions on where they can work, how they can travel, and what they
can wear. We condemn the Taliban for being oppressive and controlling.
And
they deserve that criticism.
But
I wonder if we are being selective with our outrage. What about America,
especially under President Donald Trump, and the Israeli government?
They,
too, have a long list of things they ban, restrict, sanction, or block others
from doing. In fact, while the Taliban exercise their authority primarily
within Afghanistan, American sanctions reach across the world, while Israeli
restrictions profoundly affect Palestinians living under occupation and
blockade.
Strip
away the uniforms, the flags, and the political labels, and these three are not
as different as we like to think. Consider five uncomfortable parallels.
1. They all
rule through restriction and fear.
When people or nations refuse to fall in line, all three reach for the same
tool: coercion.
·
The
Taliban ban women from classrooms and workplaces, enforcing compliance through
intimidation and arrest.
·
America,
especially under Trump, uses sanctions, tariffs, and secondary penalties,
pressuring even foreign companies and banks to cut ties with countries like
Iran out of fear of losing access to the American financial system.
·
Israel
imposes extensive controls on Palestinian movement, trade, and access to goods,
using permits, checkpoints, and blockades to dictate daily life in Gaza and the
West Bank.
People
do not necessarily comply because they agree. They comply because the cost of
defying power is too high.
2. They all
wrap coercion in a "noble" cause. Each presents its restrictions as necessary to defend
something greater.
·
The
Taliban claim they are protecting religious purity and Islamic values.
·
America
claims it is defending American greatness, freedom, democracy, and national
interests.
·
Israel
claims it is defending democracy and national security.
Notice
the contradiction. America and Israel speak about freedom and human rights, yet
use heavy-handed restrictions to force others to bend to their will. Believing
that one’s political system or way of life is superior does not give any nation
the right to impose its preferences on others.
Claiming
a noble motive does not make an oppressive method right.
3. They all
make innocent people pay the price.
This is the deepest moral flaw in all three approaches: people suffer for
decisions they did not make.
·
The Taliban: An Afghan girl is denied an education
not because of anything she did, but simply because she was born female.
·
America: An ordinary Iranian shopkeeper, factory
worker, or cancer patient is starved of livelihood and vital medicine because
of decades of sanctions imposed to serve Washington’s geopolitical interests - paying
the price for a confrontation they neither started nor control.
·
Israel: A Palestinian child loses access to
food, clean water, medicine, and , and sometimes even life itself, amid
blockades and military restrictions imposed in name of security.
If
we rightly condemn the suffering imposed on innocent people in Kabul, why
should we excuse it in Tehran or Gaza?
4. They all
crush human potential.
Every unnecessary restriction steals someone's future. We rightly grieve for
the Afghan girl robbed of her education and career. Yet we often treat the
ruined livelihoods of sanctioned Iranians or blockaded Palestinians as mere
"collateral damage" or dry economic statistics.
An
Afghan child denied schooling by a religious decree and a Palestinian child
whose school has been destroyed are both being robbed of educational
opportunities and a better future. The causes differ, but neither child's
suffering should be dismissed.
Suffering
does not hurt less just because the restriction comes from a democracy.
5. The
greater their power, the wider the damage. The Taliban primarily exercise authority within
Afghanistan. The United States, however, commands the world's dominant reserve
currency and one of its largest markets; decisions made in Washington can
weaken currencies and impoverish families thousands of kilometres away.
Israel,
likewise, exercises extensive control over Palestinian movement and trade,
including major restrictions on goods, fuel, and humanitarian assistance
entering Gaza.
With
greater power comes greater capacity to harm - and therefore a far heavier
moral duty to exercise restraint.
Let's Stop
Grading on a Curve
I
am not saying America, Israel, and the Taliban are identical. Their systems,
beliefs, and security challenges are very different, and every nation has a
right to protect itself.
What
I am saying is that we must stop
judging actions by who commits them, and start judging them by what they do to
ordinary human beings.
Right
now, we grade on a curve. When the Taliban restrict people, we call it a human
rights abuse. When Washington or Tel Aviv does it, we call it "foreign
policy" or "security strategy."
Instead
of swallowing the excuses of those in power, we should ask the same five
questions of all three:
·
Is
this restriction truly necessary?
·
Is
it fair and proportionate?
·
Are
innocent people being made to suffer?
·
How
many lives are being damaged, and for how long?
·
Is
there a more humane way to achieve the goal?
A
ban does not become righteous because it is issued in the name of God. And a
blockade or sanction does not become moral because it is issued in the name of
democracy or national security.
"Ye shall do no unrighteousness in
judgment ... but in righteousness shalt thou judge thy neighbour." - Leviticus 19:15
"And
why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not
the beam that is in thine own eye?" - Matthew 7:3–5
“ Woe to those who give less than due —
those who demand full measure when receiving from others, but give less when
measuring or weighing for them.” - Qur'an 83:1–3
Peace,
Anas Zubedy



