WHAT KIND OF ORGANISATION ARE
YOU REALLY LEADING?
Dear Captains,
Every
organisation has an official structure: organisation charts, job descriptions,
policies, procedures, reporting lines and approval limits. But these do not
necessarily tell us how the organisation actually works.
To
understand that, we must observe how authority flows, how decisions are made,
how information travels and what people have learnt to do when action is
required. Over time, repeated behaviours become habits, expectations and,
eventually, organisational culture.
The Zubedy
Leadership-Management Quadrant examines this through two axes. Formal to
Informal considers whether authority and influence come mainly from
position and hierarchy or from relationships, credibility and participation. Structured
to Unstructured considers how clearly and dependably work, decisions and
accountability are organised. Together, they produce four patterns of
leadership, management, followership and organisational behaviour.
No
organisation fits perfectly into one quadrant, and different departments may
operate differently. Nevertheless, repeated behaviour usually pulls an
organisation towards one dominant culture.
A: FORMAL AND STRUCTURED
THE COMMAND ORGANISATION
The A
organisation is hierarchical, disciplined and strongly managed. Its underlying
message is:
“I am the
boss. You listen.”
Authority is
concentrated at the top. Goals, roles and expectations are clear. Decisions are
centralised, communication is largely top-down, and performance is closely
monitored through systems, processes and numbers.
It is easy
to dismiss A as old-fashioned. That would be a mistake. It can be productive,
efficient and profitable. Military units, emergency operations, safety-critical
industries, traditional manufacturing businesses and corporate turnarounds may
require this clarity and command.
Many
successful founder-led businesses also display A characteristics. A capable and
farsighted leader can concentrate organisational energy, decide quickly and
mobilise people towards a common destination.
However, A
can produce disciplined but dependent followers. People may become excellent
executors without developing the judgement and confidence to lead
independently. Its strength is coordinated execution, but its vulnerability is
dependence on the leader. Succession planning may remain weak because the
organisation has developed capable followers without preparing enough capable
successors.
B: INFORMAL AND STRUCTURED
THE EMPOWERED ORGANISATION
The B
organisation is participative, but not leaderless. Its underlying message is:
“I am the
boss, but I listen.”
Goals and
accountability remain clear, but communication is more open. Information is
shared, employees are consulted, and authority is delegated. People have
flexibility in achieving their goals but remain answerable for the results.
Many
multinational organisations aspire towards B. They need shared standards and
dependable systems while allowing local leaders to respond to different markets
and cultures. B can scale because it does not depend entirely on one
individual. Leadership is distributed within clear boundaries.
Over time, B
creates a culture in which people contribute, exercise judgement and take
responsibility. However, B should not be confused with endless consensus.
Leaders must still decide and hold people accountable. When employees are
invited to speak but their views never influence anything, participation
becomes theatre rather than leadership.
C: INFORMAL AND UNSTRUCTURED
THE CREATIVE COLLECTIVE
The C
organisation is collaborative, experimental and loosely organised. Its
underlying message is:
“Everybody
is a boss.”
Titles carry
less weight. Ideas move freely, people challenge one another, and
experimentation is encouraged. Advertising creative teams, research
laboratories, innovation hubs and early-stage start-ups may benefit from this
environment.
C can be
powerful during exploration and ideation. Its difficulty begins when the
organisation must move from discovery to sustained execution. When everybody is
the boss, sometimes nobody is accountable. Goals become fluid, priorities
compete and decisions are repeatedly reopened. The crisis or opportunity of the
moment gradually becomes the management system.
C produces
independent and expressive followers, but their efforts may become fragmented.
It may work better as a project, creative team or temporary collaboration than
as a large permanent organisation.
Even
successful creative organisations need hidden structure. Creative work may
operate informally, but finance, compliance, project management and delivery
cannot. Freedom survives when someone builds dependable structure around it.
D: FORMAL AND UNSTRUCTURED
THE AUTHORITY-DEPENDENT ORGANISATION
The D
organisation has formal hierarchy and concentrated authority. It may also
possess extensive policies, procedures, committees and delegation-of-authority
limits. Yet its underlying message is:
“Let’s wait
for the boss.”
The systems
say that people are authorised to decide, but the culture tells them not to
proceed until those above them agree. Management asks people to take ownership,
while experience teaches them that obtaining approval is safer than exercising
judgement.
Consequently,
even small matters are sent to the boss, senior management or management
committee. D is not necessarily unstructured on paper. It is unstructured in
practice because written authority does not reliably determine how decisions
are made.
D tendencies
may be found in some public institutions, government-linked organisations,
politically influenced bodies, mature family businesses and private companies
whose governance has not kept pace with growth. They may survive through
protection, limited competition or capable employees quietly compensating for
their weaknesses. The issue is not ownership, but whether delegated authority
is genuinely allowed to operate.
D is not
always created by a controlling leader, but it often thrives under one. An
authority-dependent culture tends to select and promote leaders who equate
leadership with personal control. Its succession practices may continue
searching for another commanding figure rather than developing leaders who
delegate and build capability. The organisation sends decisions upwards, while
the leader becomes increasingly accustomed to making them. Each reinforces the
other.
A and D can
therefore look remarkably similar. Both have formal hierarchies, high power
distance and authority concentrated near the top. But they operate differently.
In A, decisions are intentionally centralised and the hierarchy concentrates
organisational energy towards execution. In D, even decisions already delegated
are repeatedly pushed upwards. The hierarchy does not concentrate energy. It
accumulates decisions.
This
distinction becomes especially important during succession. An exceptionally
capable A leader may centralise decisions and still move the organisation
forward through superior judgement, energy, foresight and clarity. However,
leaders of this calibre are rare. The danger arises when the organisation
assumes that the successor must lead in exactly the same way.
A less
capable successor may imitate the previous leader’s control without possessing
the same judgement or foresight. Instead of distributing authority and
strengthening the organisation, the successor tries to become its all-knowing
centre. What worked under an exceptional leader becomes a bottleneck. The
organisation retains the concentration of authority found in A but loses the
effectiveness and discipline that made A work. In this way, A can gradually
deteriorate into D.
WHAT DOES YOUR ORGANISATION NEED?
Dear
Captains, different businesses and institutions require different approaches. A
may suit operations demanding speed and strict control. B supports complexity
through shared standards and distributed judgement. C creates room for
experimentation and creativity. D warns against allowing formal authority to
become a culture of repeated approval.
The starting
point is awareness: recognising how the organisation actually operates, not
merely how its policies and structures say it should. From there, leaders can
determine whether the existing pattern fits the purpose, people and needs of
the business.
Where it
does not, movement towards another quadrant requires changes in how people
lead, decide, delegate and behave. A new structure alone will not create a new
culture.
The real
question is:
What kind of organisation are we leading, what kind do we need, and what
must change to get there?

No comments:
Post a Comment