Monday, July 18, 2011

Can a non-Malay be Prime Minister or Deputy Prime Minister?

I was first made conscious of this question in university in 1986. There was a talk and someone asked that question. The ensuing debate continued. At that point of time I thought that the question is rather academic and perhaps unnecessary.

Why did you think it was not necessary?

Well, in simple terms, anyone can be a leader as long as he can get enough supporters. So whether a Malay or a non-Malay can be PM is secondary to the question, 'Who has the biggest support?'

What does the constitution say about it?

The constitution does not say that the Prime Minister must be Malay. What is obvious is that our king must be Malay. The constitution suggests that the king will choose the leader who can command the support of the majority of parliamentarians. So if one day, the king considers someone to have the best possibility to lead the majority of parliamentarians, whether he or she is
Malay, Chinese, Indian, Kadazan, Eurasian, or from any other background, he will choose that person to become Prime Minister.

Why do you think this question about a non-Malay Prime Minister keeps coming

I see this as the typical Malaysian mental trap. We have a tendency to see everything too much through the racial viewpoint. Many intelligent Malaysians genuinely think that they're talking about democracy by suggesting a non-Malay PM or DPM, these kinds of things. But I think it is one of the mental sicknesses that we have, of the need to look at things from a racial perspective. To some, mostly perhaps some politicians, they may not be so clear about how leadership works. Or maybe they're deliberately using this topic to strike popularity.

Is it not democratic to ask such a question?

If we are seriously thinking about democracy and we look at it by representation, and for example we suggest the Deputy Prime Minister should be represented by someone from a race which makes up 30% of the population, why not think outside of race? We can suggest a female Deputy Prime Minister, as women are 50% of the population. Another viewpoint is instead of looking at gender, we can look at age - we have a very large population of young people. Should we also argue that we should have a Deputy Prime Minister from Gen Y? There are many ways to look at it, but we still keep falling into the race trap. So, you must ask why harp on race? Are they
simply playing politics?

So what do you suggest?

I suggest that we stop looking at race in this matter - it is a waste of time, it is an academic question. Whoever becomes the PM, DPM or ministers, whoever becomes a manager, managing director, a doctor, a lawyer - what is important is not racial representation. Even if we have ten Malays running the country, or ten Chinese or ten Indians or ten Ibans, what is important is that we have leaders who will think for everyone. Someone who thinks for all Malaysians, Malaysian first- not race.

Click here to read on this article


Anonymous said...

Yep, why not?

But first, is the candidate a MALAYSIAN?

Does she/he speak Bahasa Malaysia? Is Bahasa Malaysia "supreme" to her/him, then only comes Bahasa Inggeris? Other than these two, the language will only be for specific purposes, not becoming the "tongue"

Does he hold "supreme" the core "adat resam" orang Malaysia?

Does he respect, live by and uphold the Constitution of this country and Rukun Negara?

To help imaging these - is he "Obama" of the USA? is he "Thaksin" of Thailand?

If not, then, it is doubtful whether he is a truly anak bangsa Malaysia. Why should he have any merit as a Malaysian then? including becoming a PM candidate?

Anonymous said...

I have double minds. First question?? Do we have the political maturity?..will other races accept this situation?...not now, maybe in a few decades down the line.

Race is still a sensitive issue here, i think we should open to this idea again once we think we are more 'malaysian' than ethnic groupings.

Anonymous said...

In my honest opinion, race is no issue to be PM as long as he cares and works for rakyat and nation.

My next question is why here we emphasize race? Isn' it natural human tendency that certain race is 'important' bcos there privileges associated with bumi race?

Anonymous said...

Sir, the main thing is the PM is not self serving and not corrupt. He/She will govern wisely and will not be afraid in taking reforms to benefit the nation. That is more important than race. No point in having a non Malay if he or she is as bad as the current one. TQ